To take part in discussions on talkSFU, please apply for membership (SFU email id required).

How do you deal with....

edited August 2009 in General
....I figured instead of making individual threads, it would be kind of cool to just throw out opinions for those who are in relationships/perhaps in confusing situations?

So! I'll start.
My boyfriend and I are verrry different in terms of emotions. I'm pretty easy to read and I'll tell him how I feel, whereas he doesn't say a word and will just keep it to himself: eg. I smile a lot (when I'm happy, obviously, which is most often with him) and he rarely smiles. We were driving home tonight and I just said "smile!" and he pretty much went ballistic. Not in the physical sense, but just kept telling me that it's not him, that he finds I'm being critical, that when I leave the car he wonders what's wrong with him. I kept telling him that wasn't my intention and I was sorry if he approached it that way, but he kept telling me over and over how he thinks it means there's something wrong with the way he is.

Granted, he was tired from partying the night before. Fantastic. But does that seem appropriate? I asked if there was anything else he wanted to talk about, but he said no. It seems to me like there's underlying issues, or he's really stressed, but I didn't want to push it!

I didn't realize "smile!" was so immature/critical. Huh!

Comments

  • edited August 2009
    Its not what you said, its how you said it god!
  • edited August 2009
    Sounds like he just wants you to be comfortable with the way he is. Nobody likes to second guess themselves and he probably has been holding this in for a while from the sounds of it. Maybe him not smiling is just the way he is?? You would forsure know better than I.

    Although, going "ballistic" for what you said is an overreaction and thats why I think he has probably just been holding it in. Do you tell him things like this often? Things that make him second guess himself?
  • edited August 2009
    Like you said, you two are very different in terms of emotions...shouldn't be it left at that? I'm sure he's not the first person u've met with a stoneface.

    If you say he rarely smiles and u know this...why do u suspect he's stressed or there's some underlying issue?
  • edited August 2009
    I know he's stressed because of his job, work hours, currently studying for his CPA, etc. It make sense, I guess I was just surprised with his reaction.

    @Justin, I never, ever intentionally make him second guess himself. I always say it for fun and I told him over and over how I didn't mean it critically and there was no way I wanted to change him, but he seemed to brush it off. Like I said, I know it's stress and we're still getting to know these little things about each other, I was just really surprised.

    We also never, ever fought in our first year, and not this is a fight by any means, but coming into our second year we have wayyyy more little tiffs than we ever have. It's weird!
  • edited August 2009
    nicole;59685 said:


    We also never, ever fought in our first year, and not this is a fight by any means, but coming into our second year we have wayyyy more little tiffs than we ever have. It's weird!
    lol... wait till year 3 :tongue:
    this should be common sense tho, when u start dating, people tolerate a lot more stuff since they don't know how the person would react but once u've been with them a while some lil things can slip and u get fed up with other stuff
  • edited August 2009
    Never thought of it that way!
  • edited August 2009
    Also. Some people can feel like it's pick pick pick pick pick at something they'd rather have left alone, and don't really know how to articulate why something someone else does irritates them so much.
  • edited August 2009
    nicole;59685 said:
    I know he's stressed because of his job, work hours, currently studying for his CPA, etc. It make sense, I guess I was just surprised with his reaction.

    @Justin, I never, ever intentionally make him second guess himself. I always say it for fun and I told him over and over how I didn't mean it critically and there was no way I wanted to change him, but he seemed to brush it off. Like I said, I know it's stress and we're still getting to know these little things about each other, I was just really surprised.

    We also never, ever fought in our first year, and not this is a fight by any means, but coming into our second year we have wayyyy more little tiffs than we ever have. It's weird!
    Even if you dont intentionally make these sort of comments, which wasnt what I was trying to say, sometimes people internalize things in strange ways. Thats why I asked you if you say things like that often, even in a jokingly way. If you do, then just don't do it as much and maybe even talk to him about why he didnt say anything earlier.

    As your relationship gets more mature these things will happen more and more as bufli said. My wife and I didnt fight once in our first 1.5 years. Now its a pretty common thing, but our resolution powers are immense, lol.
  • edited August 2009
    I've definitely learned something from it at least. The thing is that he's so critical of me, jokingly, that when it's reversed it's interesting to see how he reacts.

    TalkSFU prevails again! I like outside views.
  • edited August 2009
    ill admit i also don't like it when people tell me what mood i should be in or what i should and shouldn't do
    i can't tell you why thats just how it is lol
  • edited August 2009
    I'm just a generally positive person so it's been a little difficult to be with someone who is critical/somewhat pessimistic.
    To be honest, I don't really know how we work. Haha.
  • edited August 2009
    ^ because if you were both be the same you would be bored out of your mind =P
  • edited August 2009
    True, it just seems like there's so much room for conflict!
  • edited August 2009
    lol look @ the positive aspect of conflict, it requires devotion to stick around and resolve issues ;)
  • edited August 2009
    This is true!
  • edited August 2009
    bufli;59702 said:
    ^ because if you were both be the same you would be bored out of your mind =P
    Agree. I always thought it's a myth that two similar people are perfect for each other.
  • edited August 2009
    ^ Couldnt agree more

    I also think after the first year more fights come up...and if you both get over this hump...fights will usually die down. At least this is what i'm experiencing now...i've gone out with my girl for more than 3.5 years and i feel as though we're past that stage of nick-picking little things about each other. We rarely fight now (especially over little things)! :)
  • IVTIVT
    edited August 2009
    GeoGeek;59724 said:
    ^ Couldnt agree more

    I also think after the first year more fights come up...and if you both get over this hump...fights will usually die down. At least this is what i'm experiencing now...i've gone out with my girl for more than 3.5 years and i feel as though we're past that stage of nick-picking little things about each other. We rarely fight now (especially over little things)! :)
    633571165896721034-surrenderifyoucannots
  • edited August 2009
    i was dating a guy before and he said the same thing to me one day

    theres times where i dont feel like smiling but am happy, i dont feel like people should always have to outwardly express their feelings with exubberance, and i didnt like how he told me to smile, like i have to smile to show im happy
  • edited August 2009
    randomuser;59738 said:
    i was dating a guy before and he said the same thing to me one day

    theres times where i dont feel like smiling but am happy, i dont feel like people should always have to outwardly express their feelings with exubberance, and i didnt like how he told me to smile, like i have to smile to show im happy

    It all depends on your personality.

Leave a Comment