To take part in discussions on talkSFU, please apply for membership (SFU email id required).

can a girl tell a guy that she likes him?

edited November 2009 in General
Like the title says, should a girl tell a guy (they have only known each other for about 6 months) that she likes him even though she isn't sure whether he likes her or not? Also, if he says no, can they still be friends? Would the guy think the girl is too straight forward and so the guy might be scared away?
«1

Comments

  • IVTIVT
    edited February 2009
    go for it
  • edited February 2009
    if you've known someone for six months, you should know whether they like you or not, if you dont, you either have very bad perception, or you havent explored the proper avenues in full

    it sounds like he doesnt if you don't know, and if you tell him he may think you are needy, and things won't work out

    instead of making the situation uncomfortable like that, turn up the physical contact as a way of finding out

    besides, if he doesnt like you, then what do you have to lose?
  • edited February 2009
    IVT;47614 said:
    go for it
    dont take advice from this guy


    If you know him for that long, you should be able to tell.

    If you're not sure he likes you back, it could make the situation a bit awkward.

    But yea, try getting a little closer to see how he responds to you
  • IVTIVT
    edited February 2009
    randomuser;47618 said:
    if you've known someone for six months, you should know whether they like you or not, if you dont, you either have very bad perception, or you havent explored the proper avenues in full

    it sounds like he doesnt if you don't know, and if you tell him he may think you are needy, and things won't work out

    instead of making the situation uncomfortable like that, turn up the physical contact as a way of finding out

    besides, if he doesnt like you, then what do you have to lose?
    then he will go along with it and use her for sex. that will end badly
  • edited February 2009
    How would you know? You haven't even had sex unless you ignore the bible.

    As furia said, don't take advice from this guy.

    Whether you know it or not, sex is a part of relationships, if a guy wants to have sex with a girl, or be initmate, or enjoy physical contact-- chances are he may want more than that as well.

    The only mistake you can make is having sex too soon.
  • IVTIVT
    edited February 2009
    randomuser;47626 said:
    How would you know? You haven't even had sex unless you ignore the bible.

    As furia said, don't take advice from this guy.

    Whether you know it or not, sex is a part of relationships, if a guy wants to have sex with a girl, or be initmate, or enjoy physical contact-- chances are he may want more than that as well.
    ever heard of "fuck 'n' chuck'?
  • edited February 2009
    you can go for it like ivt says which isnt all that bad
    just ask him out on a date and its done

    or ask him to go to the mall with you, if he likes you he'll go
    ..most guys hate shopping so hes gotta like you if he goes
  • edited February 2009
    IVT;47627 said:
    ever heard of "fuck 'n' chuck'?
    Yes, I've done it before.

    You only chuck them when you don't like them.
  • IVTIVT
    edited February 2009
    randomuser;47633 said:
    Yes, I've done it before.

    You only chuck them when you don't like them.
    oh
  • edited February 2009
    ...but, if you sleep with someone too early, you don't give them a chance to like you, vice versa

    Telling someone straight up isn't always the greatest approach, it'll feel too unnatural unless you're both super shy. Thats why you do a little flirting, a little playful touching, and see where it goes.
  • IVTIVT
    edited February 2009
    yeah when you put it that way, that seems like a good plan.
    personally, i like to get to the point.
  • edited February 2009
    we have feelings too. and feelings matter! we're not just a bunch of sex objects you can toy around anytime you want to. make good sexual foreplay if you want sex. don't be selfish by finishing quickly!

    ... sometimes girls could be such a bunch of insensitive jerks.
  • edited February 2009
    lmfao
  • edited February 2009
    randomuser;47641 said:

    Telling someone straight up isn't always the greatest approach, it'll feel too unnatural unless you're both super shy. Thats why you do a little flirting, a little playful touching, and see where it goes.
    As a certified Extremely Awkward Person who is admittedly completely mystified by dating conventions, let me just say that I hate this shit. It's like this secret game that everyone is playing but everyone also has completely different rules. Hence all of these threads to the effect of "oh god I really like this person I know but I don't know if the like me jesus what the fuck do I do help me internet!!!!!"

    It may be my ignorance of the Unspoken Relationship Code but these people almost never say exactly what they want, OP included. I would think that before becoming involved with someone else you might want to give some thought as to precisely what you want that involvement to entail. Whatever the case, I would favor being forthright over secret litmus tests and attempted subliminal messaging. If you ask him out or whatever and he declines for whatever reason, if you don't freak out he probably won't either. And as long as he's aware of your feelings he'll be prepared to act if he changes his mind.
  • edited February 2009
    ^ +1

    So it goes like this, girls think in a way that is way too analytical and guys think in a simple way.

    How do I come to this? I shall explain.

    Girls like to think they are sending out obvious signals to guys apparently showing they are interested in him. Guys have no clue what these "signals" are so they have no clue if she likes him or not. Girls who are also not interested tend to not want to obviously say it, again they think they are sending out obvious signals showing they are not interested, again guys cannot tell they are sending out "signals." So the summary of that paragraph is: guys cannot tell if a girl is interested in him or not because she is not being direct.

    I came home the other night, my two female roomates were complaining to each other that guys are "so complicated!" I asked what happened and they told me that the one went out to coffee with a guy and apparently after he had said, "call me when you are not busy." So these girls spent the last few hours trying to decypher what he could have possibly meant by this comment. I quickly said, "what he means if that he is interested in you and would like for you to phone him when you are not busy."

    The did not believe me, but let me tell you girls something, guys really are that simple and that is how they think, so stop over analyzing everything.
  • edited February 2009
    "call me when you are not busy."

    thats totally code for lets casually fuck
  • edited February 2009
    FerrousWheel;47711 said:
    ... never say exactly what they want, OP included.
    Online Predator included?
    thats totally code for lets casually fuck
    you deciphered it wrong. it means lets casually fuck and bring your sister with you when she's not busy too.
  • edited February 2009
    online predator;47723 said:
    Online Predator included?
    original post(er)
    JayDub;47715 said:

    I came home the other night, my two female roomates were complaining to each other that guys are "so complicated!" I asked what happened and they told me that the one went out to coffee with a guy and apparently after he had said, "call me when you are not busy." So these girls spent the last few hours trying to decypher what he could have possibly meant by this comment. I quickly said, "what he means if that he is interested in you and would like for you to phone him when you are not busy."

    The did not believe me, but let me tell you girls something, guys really are that simple and that is how they think, so stop over analyzing everything.
    umm call me when ur not buys needs to be taken in context...
    for example if i go out with a girl and she spends most of the time bitching about other shit she has to do then have an actual conversation OR shes constantly on the phone txting or something then ya.. this line means a whole new thing :P
  • edited February 2009
    It is an unfortunate truth that most men are simple creatures and often quite dense. Unless the sign that your giving him to tell him you like him involves a large placard with "I like you" on it he may not notice.

    Being upfront definitely takes the most courage; you're putting yourself out there to be rejected and it definitely isn't fun to be rejected. Some men, including myself, prefer simple upfront communication. You can make your intentions clear from the start and there won't be any misunderstandings. If he is truly your friend and cares about you he won't see this as an opportunity to use you for sex.

    It really all comes down the individual guy and how well you know him.
  • edited February 2009
    Guys: Touch her boobs to let her know you like her

    Girls: Grab his schlong.
  • edited February 2009
    Sometimes if you are new to relationships it can be hard to judge your feelings for someone...whether you are a guy or a girl. I'd have to say I agree with JayDub that girls tend to overcomplicate things whereas guys are pretty straightforward...this reminds me of the movie "He's Just Not That Into You"

    If you like him and you think he's a nice guy then you should tell him that so that you can hear how he feels. He could feel the same way about you and be experiencing the same sort of hesitation. Or, he may be interested in someone other than you which is ok too. The point is that it's better to know the truth sooner rather than later so that you can handle your relationship with him accordingly, rather than be lead on and get hurt...especially if the friendship is important to you.
  • edited February 2009
    Simon;47746 said:
    Sometimes if you are new to relationships it can be hard to judge your feelings for someone...whether you are a guy or a girl. I'd have to say I agree with JayDub that girls tend to over complicate things whereas guys are pretty straightforward...this reminds me of the movie "He's Just Not That Into You"
    People think girls are the only people that over think things, when sometimes a guy will interpret "I like you", as being needy or wanting to much attention. It goes both ways, girls are afraid to ask because of this happening. Guys do it all the time, maybe not you guys, but guys do.

    If a girl asks:

    a) If he doesn't like her, he might go around saying shes needy, and won't return her calls, etc. This is clearly a great result for someones feelings and reputation.

    b) He's fine with it, and maybe something happens of it.

    Looking at damage control, it's just easier to use physical testing to see if there is interest. It's never failed for me ever.
  • edited February 2009
    randomuser;47778 said:
    People think girls are the only people that over think things, when sometimes a guy will interpret "I like you", as being needy or wanting to much attention. It goes both ways, girls are afraid to ask because of this happening. Guys do it all the time, maybe not you guys, but guys do.

    If a girl asks:

    a) If he doesn't like her, he might go around saying shes needy, and won't return her calls, etc. This is clearly a great result for someones feelings and reputation.

    b) He's fine with it, and maybe something happens of it.

    Looking at damage control, it's just easier to use physical testing to see if there is interest. It's never failed for me ever.

    ya but see physical testing has its downside... if it works then the girl could think the guy likes her, but it could be that hes only playn along for that one occasion... and he could go around saying shes easy which again has negative effects on the girls part...

    in the end i dont think there is a way that is better then another, it depends on both people and the circumstance their in..
  • edited February 2009
    What the heck is physical testing? If you mean having sex to determine your feelings for each other than thats just whack. Sex only complicates things...if a guy is getting laid there is no way he will tell a girl honestly how he feels about her if it may result in him no longer getting laid. Straight up.
  • edited February 2009
    Simon;47849 said:
    What the heck is physical testing? If you mean having sex to determine your feelings for each other than thats just whack. Sex only complicates things...if a guy is getting laid there is no way he will tell a girl honestly how he feels about her if it may result in him no longer getting laid. Straight up.
    i doubt she means sex... more like physical contact
    which i take it would be more like hugging and random interactions with the guy
  • edited February 2009
    Physical testing is feeling the waters out without having sex.

    Putting your hand on someones leg, hugging, massages, etc. You can be very playful without going too far, and guys generally won't be physically playful, or return it back if they are not attracted to, or dislike the girl.

    All I'm saying is, touching someone won't ruin the relationships if he doesnt return the feelings, its a method of least possible harm, you can still do the straight up thing, but I'd reccommend to anyone the method of least harm first if you don't want to make things awkward.
  • edited October 2009
    No a girl should NEVER ask a guy out. It would cause all the nukes in the world to spontaneously explode thus causing the end of the world.

    On a more serious note... I dont see a problem with it. But like RU said... a lot of girls turn to physically testing their targets, and some guys do it too. Im a guy and I do it as well sometimes. However, when your testing by being physically playful, sometimes you can turn boarderline non-interest into interest as well, so be careful what you wish for!!
  • edited October 2009
    god damn this is an old thread
  • edited October 2009
    randomuser;47778 said:
    People think girls are the only people that over think things, when sometimes a guy will interpret "I like you", as being needy or wanting to much attention. It goes both ways, girls are afraid to ask because of this happening. Guys do it all the time, maybe not you guys, but guys do.

    If a girl asks:

    a) If he doesn't like her, he might go around saying shes needy, and won't return her calls, etc. This is clearly a great result for someones feelings and reputation.

    b) He's fine with it, and maybe something happens of it.

    Looking at damage control, it's just easier to use physical testing to see if there is interest. It's never failed for me ever.
    This post is a prime example of how girls overthink things.
  • edited November 2009
    Well, girls should be able to tell guys that they like 'em. Why not?

    *shrug*

Leave a Comment