›
To take part in discussions on talkSFU, please apply for membership (SFU email id required).

Philosophy writing

meeshmeesh
edited June 2008 in General
Okay, I'm usually a competent, and confident writer, but for the past few days I've been trying to write my paper for Moral Philosophy.

I'm having trouble finding the confidence to object to a concept of, oh let's say, Plato. Plato has been such an influential figure in philosophy, but as a beginner philosopher, I have certain objections to his premises, but who am I to say that his conclusions may not be valid?
And it's hard to grasp the concepts of Plato's concepts. I'm afraid I might be missing certain points that will undermine my whole objection towards one of his premises...

do you think professors/TAs care much about how valid my objection is to a premise, or are they looking for more content that I try to use to support my objection?

Comments

  • Malakaiii
    edited January 2007
    I can't speak directly for your prof/TA, but from what I've noticed in university writing, it's not so much that you know everything, but that you are making a solid attempt.

    Believe me, if people could sit down and dissect Plato's theories in the three weeks you've had to get to know them, he would not be such an influential philosopher! Your prof knows that there will be holes in your reasoning, but you should make sure you don't pretend that you know all the little details... you don't!

    Here are some general ideas on what to include:
    - ANY ideas from the lectures. The prof likes the ideas which he/she presents to you in class, and it's important for them to feel that you are digesting this info. This is the most important thing! ie: if the prof says "Plato was influential because..." or "Plato's theories have been challenged by..." be sure to work those into your essay. Not everything, of course, but pick some relevant facts to focus around.
    - What philosophers or modern ideas were influenced by Plato. Check out some encyclopedias, or your text for these ideas.
    - Plato's BIG ideas. Not all of them, but the general idea. Maybe pick some topics and give his thoughts on them? Why not mention The Cave?
    - Plato's thoughts on Morality. I'm assuming this is the focus of your course?
    - Information directly relevant to your assignment. Yes, there is a lot of info, and no, you don't have to include it all! Focus your writing and keep to the page/word count.

    Remember to have respect for the topics you address in your essay. You don't need to go overboard, but do mention that his influence is probably incalculable and that many intelligent people have devoted their lives to his theories and writings.

    I focused mainly on Plato as that's what you had mentioned, but I'm hoping you can extract something useful for yourself here! When in doubt, stick VERY CLOSELY to the assignment.

    Good luck!
  • JayDub
    edited June 2008
    Well since it is Phil it is safe to say no matter what you write your TA will mark it wrong and give you a 60%.
  • IVTIVT
    edited June 2008
    Word.
  • Makall
    edited June 2008
    As long as you keep it consistent. i.e. your points don't contradict.

    It's hard though considering it's philosophy. Cause subtle wording changes the whole meaning.

    Well, as long as you keep it consistent and have good grammar, you can pretty much just make it up as you go from what you remember in lecture. It's one of those things like an English essay where you can BS your way through.

Leave a Comment